The Cockleshell Heroes trained for months around Southsea and Langstone Harbour before setting off in December 1942, using kayaks, to blow up enemy ships in occupied France in Operation Frankton. It is reported that they used the pool for training.
The demolition of the building does not in any way diminish the great respect Portsmouth has for the Cockleshell Heroes. Their sacrifice for our freedom is commemorated with a seafront memorial near where we know they trained for their legendary raid.
Also, an island created as part of sea defence work in Langstone Harbour has recently been named ‘Cockleshell Island’ to further mark their bravery, alongside blue plaques marking their former headquarters in Spencer Road and Worthing Road in Southsea.
I’ve seen claims that a new leisure centre at Eastney will be half the cost of one at Bransbury Park. Is this true?
No, and we do not know where this estimate has come from. To build the same building at Eastney would cost the same amount – if not more to account for flood protection.
We do know that refurbishing Eastney Swimming Pool “as-is” would cost up to £8 million. However, even after this investment, the pool would:
- Remain unsuitable for early stages swimming lessons.
- Have significant accessibility issues.
- Be inconvenient for residents, too far from local schools, and poorly served by public transport.
- Still be an aging building with high ongoing maintenance costs and requiring substantial subsidies.
This £8m estimate does not include additional facilities suggested in “alternative proposals” that have been floated online. These added a learner pool, new changing rooms, a GP surgery, an open-air pool and water sports facilities. Any project to provide these additional facilities on site would have to deal with the variable ground levels there, while integrating new buildings with old. It would have to address the poor accessibility of the existing building, its poor energy rating, the fact that the pool tank leaks, and that the building needs a new roof.
It, like Bransbury Park, is also in a flood zone, but the existing building is set considerably lower in the ground. The most cost-effective way of dealing with these issues would be to demolish the existing building and build a whole new facility at a higher ground level. This would cost at least as much as building it at Bransbury Park, and probably more. It would also not fit on the footprint of the site.
This demonstrates that the alternative proposals are uncosted, unfeasible, and unrealistic.
While a new building at Bransbury Park does require significant upfront investment, it offers better value for residents in the long term by offering lower ongoing costs for the Council. This includes reduced need for subsidies as a combined pool and fitness centre, and greater energy efficiency, with a substantial portion of its power generated by solar panels on the roof.